Explanation: During the US Civil War, many troops from the North were ambivalent about slavery, or against it in only general terms.
As Union forces entered the slaver states of the South, and encountered more former slaves, their stories, and their scars, the opposition turned, in many men, from abstract and detached, to a burning hatred of the entire system of slavery imposed on their fellow man. Some choice quotes from Northern soldiers taken from the original OP’s explanation:
“With these old people were a few small Negro children from two years old up to six or seven years. There was no money in these poor old worn out slaves and the cruel and barbarous master had abandoned them to their fate. As I looked at their worn out hands and fingers and bodies I thought of the long cruel years of bondage while under burning suns and in cold and heat they had labored for this hellish system of human slavery and now in the close of nearly a century they were only a few hours from absolute want and the misery of hunger.”
“Oh! hardened depraved man, to think of owning property in men, women and children. Man, the last and noblest work of God, possessed of body, mind and soul, of passions, love and hate. All bought and sold by man for a concideration and computed in dollars and cents. Is there a just God, and will he always see his creatures thus oppressed, and not send retributive justice with a sword of vengence to teach traitors their duty, and punish them for passed offences?”
“I thought I hated slavery as much as possible before I came here, but here, where I can see some of its workings, I am more than ever convinced of the cruelty and inhumanity of the system. It has not one redeeming feature.”
Always remember one of the “classic” cowboy movies boomers absolutely love is The Outlaw Josey Wales. A very pro-Confederate, anti-Union shit movie starring Clint Eastwood.
The entire plot of the movie is a total fabrication of this exact thing, portraying Josey Wales as an innocent Confederate farmer who’s family is massacred by Northern soldiers for literally zero reason whatsoever other than “the North is evil and the South were the good guys”.
So many of the classic US westerns seems to have an ex-confederate soldier as the main protagonist for some reason.
Some truth in it - many of those who went westwards during that time were people who had, or felt like they had, nothing to lose back at home - including Confederates who had put all their eggs in the secession basket.
“For some reason” in this case being, the author was secretly Asa Earl Carter, who infamously declared “Segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever.”
He also wrote The Education Of Little Tree as pure /r/AsABlackMan native American fanfiction.
Atun-Shei has a surprisingly compassionate video about the whole thing. His focus is on Carter understanding and conveying the humiliation of having your whole shitty worldview slapped out of your hands. Gods And Generals is a blustering propaganda piece for the lost cause narrative. Josey Wales is about the little people, and it says, this is what it feels like to lose.


