Hello there dear strangers,
Thank for taking the time to read my post. I would appreciate any opinions and input from anybody. I would particularly appreciate any opinions and input from somebody who has experienced what I describe.
I will begin with a little bit of context about myself first. I am 19, I work full-time in IT, and I live semi-rural in England with my parents. I have had my license since 17, but I never had any interest in owning a car, and so I never purchased a car.
Fast-forward two years, I am trying my best not to rethink the decision, but it is hard.
-
My friends are now scattered across the country in cities hours away. Visiting them is very difficult as a result of not owning a car. I hardly get to see some of them anymore. For reference, my nearest friend lives 18 mins away by car and 2h away by public transport. My furthest friend lives 2 hours away by car and 4.5h away by public transport. Those are both one-way, so double it for a return trip.
-
I would enjoy the ability to go wherever I want, whenever I want. I do so as much as I can, but it is not the same on a bicycle and with poor public transport.
-
I feel as though my hands are tied behind my back with a lack of freedom. I don’t yet have the money (or desire) to move out, and I spend more time at home than I would like because getting to places can be a chore.
Going shopping is easy and I can stomach getting to work by a mix of cycling and getting the train, but I feel as though my social life and indeed the fun of life is suffering at the expense of my desire to remain car-free. I put this to the test over the summer, and confirmed this.
I borrowed my father’s car when he went away for one month and my life was insurmountably better. I was able to visit friends at the click of a finger, I was able to travel to beautiful remote locations, I felt a level of freedom which I have not yet felt before in life. I finally felt like an adult and not a child. I was able to go on a date with somebody who I’ve liked for years, which I would have otherwise never been able to arrange logistically.
All of that said, this is Fuck Cars isn’t it?
Cars bother me massively. The noise, the pollution, the laziness and anti-social-ness it instills on a society, the fact that motonormativity is what is holding back having decent public transport. What bothers me the most is that I don’t like where my money will be going, to the likes of large oil companies and insurance companies. I know I am preaching to the choir, but my point is that I do not ‘want’ to buy a car.
For the above reasons, I have bitterly defended and justified my decision to be car-free, to myself and to anybody who asks. I don’t know how much longer I can hold out though, however contradictory it is to what I believe. Less people using public transport discourages investment in making it better, less people cycling discourages the investment of decent infrastructure.
My beliefs are strong, but are they strong enough to be at the expense of enjoying myself while I am young?
I know that I overthink a lot, so that is why I wanted to seek the advice of others. If you were in my shoes, what might you do? If you have been in my shoes or similar, what did you do?
I would greatly appreciate any comments, suggestions, etc. :)
I would suggest to you to look into Effective Speed: taking in consideration not only the time spent driving but also all the hours of work behind owning that vehicle. You will see that public transport is one of the highest, with electrical bicycle following behind. The car has the same effective speed of bicycle, after 3-4 years
Edit: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303438453_Effective_speed_Cycling_because_it’s_faster
Amazing concept
Environmental impact aside, cars are expensive. Not only to buy but also to maintain. I think it’s great that you’re considering how you taking the train or not will send a message to the transport authorities and ultimately it does make a difference. However just because you own a car you don’t need to use it for everything, so keep that in mind.
You need to know your options and keep the costs, both time and money, in mind. You can buy a car, but you can also rent a car when you need it. That’s not very complicated anymore these days. Maybe you can come to an arrangement with your dad so he lets you borrow his car from time to time? Doesn’t have to be for free.
You can also try to make the most of your train journeys. Driving a car is always wasted time because you have to concentrate on driving and can’t do anything else. Riding the train however can be much more productive. I for example spend a lot of my time in trains writing, I do most of my work on my DSA campaign on the train. Even just spending the time researching stuff or ordering things you need to buy makes it feel more productive.
An E-Bike or a moped could be an option at least for the shorter journey to the friend who lives close by.
You need to weigh how important not owning a car is to you. In rural areas not owning a car can be quite tough, as you know, but doable. Just don’t be afraid to rent one. You’re saving so much money by not owning a car that you can rent one from time to time.
Unfortunately you live in a world built for cars. IMO you can still be anti car, still work against them in whatever way you see fit, and still prioritize other modes of transport, while also using a car to the extent to be able to reach people and live your life.
Buy the car. Preferably a small ev. Be a good driver. Vote and work towards a future where you don’t need the car to visit friends.
Rent or borrow a car for a weekend every few months. Visit the friends, go to that far-away museum, then go back home and start biking and walking again.
It’s not a binary choice. It’s not all or nothing. Instead, focus on minimizing car usage as much as possible.
This is also the most economical choice. Less payments, less maintenance, less parking needed, but also saving time and energy switching from walking to bus to train to bus to walking on impossibly long trips.
Fuck cars, and the people who wouldn’t give a shit about any of this. Oh, fuck bikes, too. Fucking sidewalk assholes, fuck right off into the street.
I get your position from sort of the opposite side of the aisle.
I grew up in quite a rural area (Midwest USA) and it never quite clicked with me what was wrong. I got my drivers license in high school, just like everyone else had to to get around. But then I enrolled in school at a larger university. Once I was in the middle of a campus centered in a midsize city, I finally felt like I had real freedom being able to walk or bike wherever I wanted. The public transit still sucks, but the few square km around campus were the best urban area I had experienced in a long time.
Fast forward to last year and I graduated, and then came the job search. I work in software and the job market last year sucked. I already knew I had to work in the city somewhere because there were no jobs in my field where I live at home. My partner however, hated the city and would not move more than 30 minutes from home by car. I am not entirely opposed either, as much as I loved walking everywhere, I did grow up in a rural area and that will stay a part of me.
Unfortunately I have just had to accept that I will never live in my urbanist utopia in my life time. I did end up with a job in the same city I went to college and I now have to drive over an hour both ways. However, I love my partner and seeing my family and friends more than walking. The best I can do now is try to make my local community better, and on the off chance we ever get rail coming through my area, start to take a train.
I would say get a small EV, drive carefully, and still take other transportation wherever possible. Don’t deprive yourself of happiness because of the the world others built for you. Just do what you can to make it better!
sorry if i wasn’t able to parse it from the text, but is there any reason you can’t just… get an electric moped?
there are electric moped cars if you want protection from the weather and a bit more safety:

Get real.
One more car on the roads is meaningless.
On the other hand, if you use your car to get people to the polls on election day, or use it to help at a food bank, you’re helping the community.
Step back and look at the bigger picture.
It’s a question of priorities and values. You can construct a perfectly awesome life without a car. But you have to be selective. While your life can still be any arbitrary degree of awesome, it cannot be fully arbitrary in content. You will certainly have to make compromises and sacrifices in the specifics. Maybe you can’t sacrifice that one person you want to be able to see. But when it’s no longer a matter of mere privilege (eg disability or poverty are forcing the issue) a person typically manages to find a way to be car free.
I’ve discovered that after decades of walking around town, I have developed a fear of being a passenger in a car. I think it would be better if I were driving, but perhaps better still if I don’t find out…


