If we take the time to analyse the flow of content relating to video games seriously, we will see that it consists mainly of structuring imperatives that shape the social and cultural space of gamers. Guides show players how to play well; reviews judge games as good or bad; ‘let’s play’ videos demonstrate what to do and often double as guides and reviews, as do live streams, and so on. Games, in turn, adapt and incorporate into their mechanics and requirements the participation of a community that is less collaborative than it is prescriptive. Thus, in principle, asynchronous collaboration within the Dark Souls series seems to enrich these desolate worlds with welcome presences. But in practice, what we mainly encounter in-game are dubious jokes, directives and advice. Everywhere – from online interactions with other players to Steam pages, specialist websites and the physical game covers – insurmountable norms are being established for anyone wishing to play. It all seems so natural that we forget none of this behaviour was necessary; that appreciative discourse could have been based on sensory experience; that our gameplay could have unfolded quite differently. The only inevitable feature of the gaming landscape—shaped by the countless discussions and stances taken by its players—is its fractured topology, its conflictual nature.

This is basically Dan Olson’s thesis in “Why It’s Rude to Suck at Warcraft”. How even ostensibly “communal” and informal forms of interaction end up being top-down, authoritarian, and devoid of individual expression in the gamer-space.